Announcement

Collapse
No announcement yet.

Standing in the Shadow Inventory

Collapse
X
 
  • Filter
  • Time
  • Show
Clear All
new posts

  • Standing in the Shadow Inventory

    Did Bernanke Permanently Cripple the Butterfly That Is US Housing? The Answer Is More Obvious Than Many Want To Believe


    As excerpted from Do Black Swans Really Matter? Not As Much as the Circle of Life, The Circle Purposely Disrupted By Multiple Central Banks Worldwide!!!, Bernanke et. al. have snipped the chrysalis of the US markets and economy one too many times. He has interrupted the circle of life…

    I have always been of the contention that the 2008 market crash was cut short by the global machinations of a cadre of central bankers intent on somehow rewriting the rules of economics, investment physics and global finance. They became the buyers of last resort, then consequently the buyers of only resort while at the same time flooding the world with liquidity and guarantees. These central bankers and the countries they allegedly strive to serve took on the debt and nigh worthless assets of the private sector who threw prudence through the window during the “Peak” phase of the circle of economic life, and engaged in rampant speculation.



    The result of this “Great Global Macro Experiment” is a market crash that was never completed.

    A snapshot of the housing picture as of now, before the release of the latest Case Shiller numbers


    Here are a few observations that we have made regarding the March data. The last quarter of 2010 and portions of the first quarter of 2011 have seen a significant drop in foreclosure activity due to allegations and blatant discoveries of fraudulent practices in the mortgage industry.

    This near cessation of foreclosure activity has materially dropped the shadow inventory numbers, but has done so in a way that is quite misleading. Those foreclosures either will happen and become REOs or distressed property sales that are currently averaging a discount of ~25% to conventional retail sales (thus further pressuring sales prices), or will result in the properties being put directly on the market at steep discount (again, further pressuring sale prices). Basically, the foreclosure backlog is simply accumulating in the background and will print a very sharp spike upwards one way or another once the foreclosure and fraud issues of the banks are sorted out – even if they are sorted out to the detriment of the banks. Despite this reprieve in foreclosures, the ratio of shadow inventory to home sales is not decreasing. This is a double negative, for shadow inventory is decreasing (albeit for very artificial and temporary reasons). The reason for the lack of movement in this very key figure is that housing sales are actually declining both on a seasonally adjusted and non-adjusted basis – and if these figures were to be adjusted for “true” inflation, would look much worse. This leaves the ratio of delinquent and foreclosure activity to sales relatively static. One can surmise what happens when the foreclosure backlog that was caused by the bank’s myriad legal issues clear up.

    The most valuable chart in the study just released to subscribers, Shadow Inventory Update — March 2011 shows how quickly one can expect the shadow inventory to be consumed by the sale of homes. To make a long story short, we still have quite a ways to go before we reach the pre-bubble levels, and that is without taking into consideration the foreclosure moratoriums. Keep in mind that these numbers do not include the pent up shadow inventory that is being hidden by the foreclosure crisis. That additional inventory on top of a slowing housing sales metric can easily tack one to 4 years onto the inventory numbers.




    As you can see, the credit (delinquency measures) metrics are actually moderating slightly over the last few quarters, but have increased over the last two. This is a negative sign considering all of the efforts that have been made by the government and the banks to reduce that figure. The foreclosure inventory, although lulled somewhat, is still slightly on the rise. This lull is synthetic and temporary, a by-product of congressional pressure and legal issues pressing the banks to undergo voluntary and involuntary moratoriums on foreclosure activity. The consequent movement to be expected as these moratoriums are lifted, the banks work out their legal issues, and the properties move one way or the other will cause a very dramatic spike in the shadow inventory numbers. This spike will occur on top of slowing housing sales, dramatically reduced housing prices metrics and potentially deteriorating credit metrics (if the most recent trend continues). If that is not enough good news for you, the Goldilocks scenario of the perfect interest rate environment for real estate needs to (and probably will in the near to medium term) come to an end.

    Our calculations show a very bleak outlook for housing. It is not as if there is no precedence for such. Take a look at the Japanese situation, and this is not taking into consideration the recent issues of the earthquake, tsunami and radiation poisoning and nuclear meltdown. Few things are as detrimental to property values as radiation poisoning!




    A lesson to be learned: Beware for when a true black swan event occurs…


    http://boombustblog.com/reggie-middl...eve/#more-5188



  • #2
    Re: Standing in the Shadow Inventory

    So Don have you and your bride purchased a home yet?

    Comment


    • #3
      Re: Standing in the Shadow Inventory

      Not yet Jersey. We go in June to look on the ground. Might make an offer. If not, the Fall and will rent if we have to wait them out.

      Comment


      • #4
        Re: Standing in the Shadow Inventory

        Are you in the Northeast or West?

        I my area - New Jersey - lots of inventory with the exception of Towns directly adjacent to Wall Street. Any nice Towns within 45 minute train ride to Wall Street are doing fairly well - else where there is lots of softness.

        Comment


        • #5
          Re: Standing in the Shadow Inventory

          Originally posted by BK View Post
          Any nice Towns within 45 minute train ride to Wall Street are doing fairly well - else where there is lots of softness.
          I'm originally from eastern Bergen County. Zillowing my childhood home, nice town minutes to the Hudson, I see it supposedly peaked at about $1mm (total joke), sold last in 2009 for $445k (after having been for sale for about four years--I'd seen the for sale sign in 2005 when visiting for our 30th reunion), now zalued at $400k. An old friend there is about to put his house (previously his mom's house) up for sale, zillow shows him about 50% off peak. Another old friend had moved out to the Franklin Lakes area, western Bergen (where there were about 12 homes for sale in his area when he listed, now realtor.com shows more than 10x's that) and zillow has him down about 30% though he insists he is only down 20%. He's been trying to sell for 2 years now. Only one offer so far and that then walked. He's getting nervous.

          I'm not sure why the above graphic shows a break before contraction because another one of my old group of school friends recently contracted pneumonia, dying just days ago. It is the saddest recession story I'm personally aware of. Unaware of bubbles, he paid $230k for a home in Arizona in 2005. He put down $140k to keep mortgage payments low and because he thought it was a safe place to store money. He then upgraded (am I the only person in the world without granite?). It now might be worth $90-100k. He lost his job in construction and went to trade school for HVAC or refrigeration, I forget. Still unable to locate work locally, he finally took a job in Alaska. I just spoke with him a few weeks ago, before he left. Then just a week or two ago he got sick, wound up in the hospital and then started bleeding in the brain. His wife, a retired nurse 15 years our senior who gets just $600/month social security because she started drawing at 62, took our friend off his respirator the other day. He was a terrible smoker who did not exercise + stress of crash + losing job + losing all his equity (which was previously his actual cash) + retraining late in life + starting new job + relocation to Alaska = death.

          We figure if she sold everything, she might have $25k to her name at about age 70. Seems it's certainly contracting for some of us.
          Last edited by housingcrashsurvivor; March 30, 2011, 01:20 PM.

          Comment


          • #6
            Re: Standing in the Shadow Inventory

            Reggie assumes that this "shadow inventory" will eventually be sold.

            It reminds me of all the hoopla over how the FED will be able to shrink their balance sheet.

            #########

            The banks have free money. They do not need to sell houses. They can let them rot (literally). The FED has not only failed to save our imaginary wealth, but it is also successfully destroying our nation's real wealth as these homes deteriorate . In a few more years the best investment will be in bulldozer companies.

            Comment


            • #7
              Re: Standing in the Shadow Inventory

              The Wall Street Examiner (audio) does an excellent analysis of the current blip in housing prices.

              http://wallstreetexaminer.com/podcas...3011-part1.mp3

              Comment

              Working...
              X