Announcement

Collapse
No announcement yet.

For Starvin' Steve

Collapse
X
 
  • Filter
  • Time
  • Show
Clear All
new posts

  • For Starvin' Steve

    previous next
    Incoming student Miles Fries, 10, above, carries a cushion to help ready the East Bay School for Boys in Berkeley.


    East Bay School caters to boys' learning styles


    Like most boys, Joe Villeneuve's son, Dylan, is not one for sitting still.

    "He's a bouncy, outgoing, happy kid who likes to explore and see how things work," said the Berkeley father. "He's always on the move. He is a boy."

    And as every parent and teacher will attest, "always on the move" and a quiet, orderly classroom are not always compatible states.

    But Dylan will soon be at a school where "always on the move" is not only prized, it's built into the curriculum. The East Bay School for Boys, opening Aug. 31 in Berkeley, is tailored specifically to boys' energy levels, brain development and love of taking things apart, scattering them across the floor and putting them together again.

    The first week of school, for example, the boys will get hammers, power saws and wood, and build their own desks.

    "We're going to allow them to make mistakes, experiment, be a little disorganized," said headmaster Jason Baeten. "It's going to be messy, but we think they'll fall in love with school."

    Boys need to fall back in love with school, according to several recent studies.

    In the past 30 years or so, boys have started trailing girls in reading, writing, grades, test scores and overall motivation, according to a report compiled by educators, sociologists and others who want the president to establish a White House Council on Boys to Men. In 1966, men earned 61 percent of the college diplomas in the United States, but are expected to earn only 39 percent by 2019, their report stated.

    Boys are also more likely to be medicated for attention problems and learning disorders, and more likely to be held back or disciplined for behavior problems, studies show.

    End to sitting all day

    In many cases, boys are performing the same as they always have but girls have surged ahead academically, due in part to a general shift in curriculum favoring girls. It wasn't hard: More than 90 percent of elementary and middle school teachers are women.

    Another factor is higher academic expectations placed on younger children due to pressure to raise test scores, teachers said. Kindergarteners are now expected to read, a task that's difficult for some boys because their language skills generally develop later than girls'. The result is that by first grade, many boys are already lagging and their self-confidence starts to drag.

    "The structure of a classroom - sitting still in a desk all day - works better for girls than boys," said Marcia Bedford, an East Bay School for Boys board member and assistant head of school at Julia Morgan School for Girls in Oakland. "There's a lot of pressure on boys to hold it together all day and behave, well, like girls."

    Boys schools blossom

    East Bay School for Boys isn't the only new school to take on boys' education. Public, private and charter schools for boys are blossoming throughout much of the United States, according to the International Boys School Coalition.

    "These schools take boys as they are. Instead of punishing boys for their activity, they embrace it and build the curriculum around it," said executive director Brad Adams. "These schools have had great success."

    The Pacific Boychoir Academy in Oakland, an all-boys school that opened seven years ago, tailored its curriculum to boys. History classes focus on conflicts and action, teachers might cover four lessons instead of two in a 50-minute period in order to keep students interested, and boys get plenty of opportunities to run around.

    Directed energy

    "Boys are naturally competitive and we don't want to tamp that down," said school administrator Jim Gaines. "We want to give boys a chance to be extraordinary."

    The hope for all these schools is to create a generation of males who are self-confident, capable and compassionate in a world where men's roles are in flux, Baeten and others said.

    Joe Villeneuve is just hoping his son's natural enthusiasm isn't squelched by having to sit still at a desk all day.

    "What a luxury for a school to say, we're going to use all that energy," he said. "We're not going to thwart it."

    http://www.sfgate.com/cgi-bin/articl...BA371ESO38.DTL

  • #2
    Re: For Starvin' Steve

    the boys will get hammers, power saws
    This could get off to a slow start.

    Comment


    • #3
      Re: For Starvin' Steve

      Originally posted by dummass View Post
      This could get off to a slow start.
      ... He said offhandedly...
      If necessity is the mother of invention, desperation is the father...

      Comment


      • #4
        Re: For Starvin' Steve

        "Without some risk, there's no reward"

        retired shop teacher George "Stubby" McGirk

        Comment


        • #5
          Re: For Starvin' Steve

          Great Idea, I think.

          Comment


          • #6
            Re: For Starvin' Steve

            Despite the smart-ass remarks, me too!

            Comment


            • #7
              Re: For Starvin' Steve

              Excellent idea. I hope they are very successful. Of course, if they are successful they will be sued by some parent who wants their daughter to get in there. And then, we will be back to square one.

              Comment


              • #8
                Re: For Starvin' Steve

                Joe Villeneuve is just hoping his son's natural enthusiasm isn't squelched by having to sit still at a desk all day.
                Oh come on. Self control squelches enthusiasm now? What if little Bobby starts squirming at the board meetings when he is all grown up? Or can't sit still while his boss is speaking? The self control and discipline learned in the typical classroom will pay dividends in the world we live in today. Seems to me this type of class for boys would have been a better idea 100 years ago when boys grew up to be manly men. Today they'll be more likely to need that self control to keep from going crazy in some cubicle.

                "There's a lot of pressure on boys to hold it together all day and behave, well, like girls."
                Excellent practice for the 21st century man.

                Comment


                • #9
                  Re: For Starvin' Steve

                  While on generalization, it is true that most boys learn differently than most girls do, what I don't like to see in education is sex-segregation, i.e, boys' schools and girls' schools, boys' classes and girls' classes.

                  In other words, and to be politically-incorrect here, what I don't want to see in public education in the Western World is an Islamic approach to education, i.e, sex-segregation.

                  I would much rather see a complete reform of the public-school curriculum, especially in America where that curriculum dates back to the early 19th C. Accommodations have to be made in gender-integrated classrooms for the different way people learn, including boys. And for both genders, the curriculum has to be relevant to the world job market and not to the standardized timed-testers.

                  Comment


                  • #10
                    Re: For Starvin' Steve

                    [QUOTE=Starving Steve;171582]While on generalization, it is true that most boys learn differently than most girls do, what I don't like to see in education is sex-segregation, i.e, boys' schools and girls' schools, boys' classes and girls' classes.

                    Prove it

                    Cindy

                    Comment


                    • #11
                      Re: For Starvin' Steve

                      [QUOTE=cindykimlisa;171587]
                      Originally posted by Starving Steve View Post
                      While on generalization, it is true that most boys learn differently than most girls do, what I don't like to see in education is sex-segregation, i.e, boys' schools and girls' schools, boys' classes and girls' classes.

                      Prove it

                      Cindy
                      I hate to use SAT scores to prove anything because I believe the test scores are bogus and don't measure anything except test-taking skills; nevertheless, for the sake of argument here, I refer you here to SAT scores which show that males scored 530 in math and females 503; males 513 in verbal reasoning, females 505. (ref. 2005 SAT ) You may check other years, but 2005 was the latest that I could find info in the table of SAT test scores. Each year, a similar gender difference appeared.... Interesting, females scored higher than males on the writing samples in the SAT. What that proves, I don't know.
                      Last edited by Starving Steve; August 16, 2010, 07:11 PM.

                      Comment


                      • #12
                        Re: For Starvin' Steve

                        This is the only part that seemed to be stretching it a bit...the part about "putting them together again"...there's no fun in that.

                        Originally posted by don View Post
                        ...The East Bay School for Boys, opening Aug. 31 in Berkeley, is tailored specifically to boys' energy levels, brain development and love of taking things apart, scattering them across the floor and putting them together again...

                        ...

                        Comment


                        • #13
                          Re: For Starvin' Steve

                          Originally posted by GRG55 View Post
                          This is the only part that seemed to be stretching it a bit...the part about "putting them together again"...there's no fun in that.
                          "We want to give boys a chance to be extraordinary."

                          That also seems a stretch. How about settling for…

                          "All the women are strong, all the men are good looking, and all the children are above average."

                          Comment


                          • #14
                            Re: For Starvin' Steve

                            My first technical project was a Waltham Watch when I was five - wind up watches don't go back together as easily as they come apart.

                            At 11 yrs I wiretapped the Family telephone line and recorded my 14 year old sisters phone calls. No manual or class instruction required.

                            At 12 I dismantled my parents gas power lawn mower - it wasn't working - I had absolutely no understanding of how a Briggs&Stratton engine worked - of course I ended up with lots of extra parts. I did learn a great deal. That Spring we return the Lawn Mower to Sears and received store credit for the Lawn mower I dissected.

                            Interest in taking things apart and working on them seems to be more often a Male trait. I had 4 sisters and none any interest in my technical mis-adventures. The women who is really good at technical is a rare bird......surely there is a difference between men and women.....can society really be responsible for the massive difference????

                            Has anyone ever passed by a private home garage and seen a woman feverishly working on an old Car or Truck........ever?????
                            Last edited by BK; August 18, 2010, 09:14 AM. Reason: spelling

                            Comment


                            • #15
                              Re: For Starvin' Steve

                              Originally posted by GRG55 View Post
                              This is the only part that seemed to be stretching it a bit...the part about "putting them together again"...there's no fun in that.
                              Only if you put things together ignoring the instructions. I've always been attracted to that approach.

                              Comment

                              Working...
                              X