Re: Denial springs eternal
In my opinion, most of general public opinion about Nafta results of comparisons with the pre-NAFTA situation in both US, Canada and Mexico.
While we had a protective state up to the 70's here in Mexico, that built the default and crisis prevailing since 1973, both industry and service jobs were mostly life jobs, and production was intended just for local consumption in manufactured appliances, exports of Mexican manufactured stuff was a novelty in 1985, now there are things that are produced around here and distributed throughout the world (Most VW Beetles are produced in San Martín Texmelucan, Puebla, Most PT Cruisers are made in Toluca, México and at least once all the HP inkjet printers were made in El Salto, Jalisco)
Most of the hype at the time when we joined GATT was that internal manufacture was not of high quiality, since it was protected against foreign competition, as well as local agriculture, banking and market distribution. Same happened with NAFTA.
In the middle 80's, when I was in High School, most of our teachers told us that the intention of opening trade with the rest of the world was "to devastate local industry, opening it to transnationals, and turn our agriculture to support only horticulture". In that aspect, they haven't been fully wrong or fully right, but the nationalist rethoric under which most people grew, makes us tend to dismiss more the good aspects of the treaty than the negative ones. And IMHO, it is a similar development and feeling in both US and Canada.
Originally posted by Finster
View Post
While we had a protective state up to the 70's here in Mexico, that built the default and crisis prevailing since 1973, both industry and service jobs were mostly life jobs, and production was intended just for local consumption in manufactured appliances, exports of Mexican manufactured stuff was a novelty in 1985, now there are things that are produced around here and distributed throughout the world (Most VW Beetles are produced in San Martín Texmelucan, Puebla, Most PT Cruisers are made in Toluca, México and at least once all the HP inkjet printers were made in El Salto, Jalisco)
Most of the hype at the time when we joined GATT was that internal manufacture was not of high quiality, since it was protected against foreign competition, as well as local agriculture, banking and market distribution. Same happened with NAFTA.
In the middle 80's, when I was in High School, most of our teachers told us that the intention of opening trade with the rest of the world was "to devastate local industry, opening it to transnationals, and turn our agriculture to support only horticulture". In that aspect, they haven't been fully wrong or fully right, but the nationalist rethoric under which most people grew, makes us tend to dismiss more the good aspects of the treaty than the negative ones. And IMHO, it is a similar development and feeling in both US and Canada.
Comment